Flack wrote:Without naming them, I have seen 5 of the movies on this list. I will make it a priority to watch the rest of them.
You can skip The Game and Panic Room, if those weren't part of the 5.
Based on the tale of the tape, how do the two latest films match up against one another?
Gone Girl is a long-ass atmospheric thriller, which Fincher has shown he can do well. Also, his last movie was sub-par, and if you've been following my analysis of Fincher's career, you know that EVERY OTHER MOVIE he makes is great. The pattern continues to this day. Just to review:
Alien3: BOOO
Se7en: YAAAY
The Game: BOOO
Fight Club: YAAAAAAAAAAAAY
Panic Room: BOOOO
Zodiac: YAAAAAY
Benjamin Button: BOOOOOOOOOOO
Social Network: YAAAAAY
Girl with the Dragon Tattoo: BOOOOOO
Gone Girl: ?!?!?!?!?!?!
On the other side, it's less clear, as Inherent Vice is a complete departure for PTA:
1. For the first time, it's based directly on a book.
2. For the first time, it appears to be a Coen-esque detective story with comedic/stoner overtones.
3. For the first time, it's set in NON-present day Los Angeles.
4. For the second time, Philip Seymour Hoffman is not present. (And for the first time, was unavailable. :( )
So with all we know at this point, Fincher seems primed for a win.
However, never count Ol' Scruffy Beard out!

[quote="Flack"]Without naming them, I have seen 5 of the movies on this list. I will make it a priority to watch the rest of them.[/quote]
You can skip The Game and Panic Room, if those weren't part of the 5.
[quote]Based on the tale of the tape, how do the two latest films match up against one another?[/quote]
Gone Girl is a long-ass atmospheric thriller, which Fincher has shown he can do well. Also, his last movie was sub-par, and if you've been following my analysis of Fincher's career, you know that EVERY OTHER MOVIE he makes is great. The pattern continues to this day. Just to review:
Alien3: BOOO
Se7en: YAAAY
The Game: BOOO
Fight Club: YAAAAAAAAAAAAY
Panic Room: BOOOO
Zodiac: YAAAAAY
Benjamin Button: BOOOOOOOOOOO
Social Network: YAAAAAY
Girl with the Dragon Tattoo: BOOOOOO
Gone Girl: ?!?!?!?!?!?!
On the other side, it's less clear, as Inherent Vice is a complete departure for PTA:
1. For the first time, it's based directly on a book.
2. For the first time, it appears to be a Coen-esque detective story with comedic/stoner overtones.
3. For the first time, it's set in NON-present day Los Angeles.
4. For the second time, Philip Seymour Hoffman is not present. (And for the first time, was unavailable. :( )
So with all we know at this point, Fincher seems primed for a win.
However, never count Ol' Scruffy Beard out!
[img]http://media.timeout.com.br/contentFiles/image/saopaulo/06_FILM/films/T/the-master/paul-thomas-anderson_bx_max-rossi_reuters.jpg[/img]